Muntashir, who has written lyrics for movies resembling “Kesari” and Ajay Devgn’s newest OTT launch, had uploaded the controversial video titled “Who’re your ancestors” on Twitter on August 24. Some individuals, together with filmmaker Vivek Ranjan Agnihotri, additionally spoke in his assist.
आप किसके वंशज हैं ?Select Your Legacy And Your Heros!Relwasing as we speak at 5 PM on YouTube/Manoj Muntashir https://t.co/Xi9Mq1GGSf
— Manoj Muntashir (@manojmuntashir) 1629788156000
The one-minute video has him on-screen declaring that the nation had been brainwashed and roads have been named after “glorified dacoits” like Akbar, Humayun and Jehangir.
“Cringe. Dangerous poetry, unwatchable. Ought to drop the pen title too. Why revenue off of one thing you so hate,” actor Richa Chadha stated, referring to his pen title “muntashir”.
Bigotry laced with casteism! https://t.co/7ok09YCql4
— Neeraj Ghaywan (@ghaywan) 1629961135000
The 45-year-old from Madhya Pradesh dropped Shukla from his title to tackle “muntashir”, which suggests ‘scattered’ or ‘dispersed’, in response to the Rekhta dictionary.
“Masaan” director Neeraj Ghaywan criticised him for his poetry and stated, “Bigotry laced with casteism!”
Fellow lyricist and screenwriter Mayur Puri added that writers should not act as enablers of hate with their work.
“Why seed hatred, Manojbhai? No nation has a superbly rosy historical past. Par writers ko aag lagaane ka nahin, aag bujhane ka kaam karna chahiye. (However writers ought to attempt to put out the hearth, not unfold it)
“Please do not thoughts, however I am a bit upset that you’re doing this sort of work,” Puri wrote.
Because the outrage unfold, ‘Mughals’ began trending on Twitter with greater than 20,000 tweets on the subject.
Husain Haidry, one other lyricist author, claimed this wasn’t the primary time Muntashir was “spreading hate or lies” and it will not be the final.
“Masks has been off since effectively over a yr. This isn’t an out-of-the-blue video. Anyway, spewing anti-Muslim venom, as a substitute of being punished, has now been incentivised by the federal government and the society…,” the “Mukkabaaz” lyricist wrote.
Lyricist-poet Puneet Sharma got here up with a reply within the type of a Hindi poem, titled “Dakshin ke naa vaam ke, na Allah ke naa Ram ke, netaji ke naukar sab, bhookhe hain inaam ke.” (They do not belong to both proper or left, Allah or Ram, they’re the servants of the chief, and search rewards)
“Who taught this man historical past? What is going to he name the Maratha invasion of Bengal?” requested creator Devdutt Pattanaik.
Including his voice to the controversy, historian S Irfan Habib stated it was disappointing to see a author like Muntashir “spitting venom” and utilizing “doubtful and imaginary arguments as historical past”.
One Twitter person wrote that “mediocre artists” have been taking part in anti-Muslim “hate-mongering” to additional their profession.
A piece on Twitter got here out in assist of Muntashir and argued that the author was merely reminding individuals of the “forgotten precise historical past” of the nation and the Mughals.
Filmmaker Agnihotri tweeted, “Manoj Muntashir has all the time been expressing his perspective fearlessly in his poetry and public discourse. If you’re ignorant doesn’t suggest he has modified instantly. ”
In his video, Muntashir additionally refers back to the title of gods being faraway from historical past textbooks and asks how individuals can name Mughal emperors “noble kings” after they had “massacred individuals” within the title of faith.
He stated individuals ought to select their heroes and villains with none caste bias.
Source link
